A Hilltop Montauk Home with a Country Club Feel Asks $12.85M

July 01, 2026
by

Perched on a 1.74-acre hilltop with mega-watt views of the Atlantic, a gated compound at 283 Old Montauk Highway has it all, including a swanky putting green that adds a playful country club touch to the estate. Listed for $12.85 million (reflecting a recent price cut of $1.65 million), the 8,200-square-foot residence spans three levels and includes six bedrooms and 10 baths.

A grand entry foyer, dual staircases, stone fireplaces, and a wraparound porch made for hosting cocktail parties and summer suppers lend the home a relaxed charm, though a new owner may seek to update the interiors. A chef’s kitchen and spacious common areas flow outdoors, where bluestone terraces give way to a heated infinity pool and spa and perennial gardens that bloom all season.

The outdoor space upstairs is also undeniably unique. Each en-suite bedroom, including a primary with fireplace, walk- in closet, and marble bath, boasts a private porch and 180-degree views of the Atlantic. Meanwhile, a nine-seat theater, gym, game room, and oversized garage occupy the lower level.

Eve Combemale of Sotheby’s International Realty holds the listing, which is close to Gurney’s Montauk Resort and some of the South Fork’s most dramatic beaches.

This article appears in the July 1, 2026 issue of HC&G (Hamptons Cottages & Gardens).

Load More