Identical twins Rosie Dolly and Jenny Dolly, also known as The Dolly Sisters, were Broadway and vaudeville icons of New York City’s glamorous, lively 1920s era. While they dazzled on stage and had dramatic personal lives, that didn’t mean they always wanted to be under a spotlight. In 1924, they constructed this White Plains manor as a summer oasis where they could escape Manhattan. When wanting to get away from their main residence on the Upper West Side, they’d retreat to enjoy peace and quiet here. Now, that very same property can be yours for $2.795 million.
Taking inspiration from the Newport, Rhode Island’s “cottages,” the home shows off grandeur with robust details yet is certainly more comfortable and less opulent than Marble House or The Breakers. Dark brick, coffered roofing, and verdant landscaping make the exterior cheerful and inviting. Much has been preserved from the Dolly Sisters’ time here. The main floor’s wide-plank floors, woodwork detailing, and many original features have all been kept intact, serving as a rich piece of Dolly Sisters history. While they came here to relax, its likely they also threw their fair share of 1920s shindigs, too. The new owner can also entertain with panache all year, as the residence promises vast living rooms and 1.12 acres.
The connection to the outdoors doesn’t feel forced or like it’s trying too hard, just simple suburban charm. If the serenity gets old sometimes, it’s also in a prime location just minutes from downtown White Plains, Metro-North, and all kinds of shopping and dining.
Just waiting for someone to give it new shine with some stylish updates, this piece of Broadway history is listed with Stacey Pinkas and John Oliveria of Douglas Elliman.
