An Upstate New York House with 1740s Roots and a Unique Addition by Architect John Mesick Seeks $2.8M

Few homes can successfully blend centuries with seamless confidence as this historic home for sale in Upstate New York does. Tucked in the bucolic countryside, with over eight acres of former orchards and farmland, Hardwicke Farmhouse dates back to the 18th-century but was more recently reimagined by architect John Mesick, who crafted an unexpected modern addition.

Mesick, a founding partner of MCWB architects and contemporary of I.M. Pei, gave the home new dimension through bold lines, wood ceilings, and a “silo-inspired” great room. “The midcentury addition is really interesting and gives a contemporary flair to the house,” its listing agent, Anthony D’Argenzio, told the Realtor.com. “It has a big fireplace and a lot of glass, offering views of its incredible setting. You feel like you are in a snow globe or a nature preserve.”

After initially listing for $3.25 million in late 2024 and raising the price to $3.45 million without finding a buyer, the home has been relaunched for $2.75 million, a nearly $700,000 price cut. “There is a lot of value for what you are getting; it feels like a massive estate,” D’Argenzio said.

The original structure dates back to the 1740s and boasts colonial craftsmanship. Its roots are apparent in traditional hand-hewn beams, wide-plank floors, restored hardware, and Dutch doors. A Greek Revival-style hall was added in the 1840s, boasting quiet corners and cozy spaces ideal for a morning cup of coffee or an afternoon read. There are three ensuite bedrooms, four bathrooms, and an adorable eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances. A pool lies just beyond the house, with two freshwater springs and weathered barns nearby as well.

Enticing for history lovers on many levels, the property is also set in Kinderhook, the town where Martin Van Buren, the Eighth President of the United States, was born. Interested? Contact D’Argenzio of This Old Hudson Team at Houlihan Lawrence to learn more.