Tour a Renovated 1880-Built Retreat on Martha’s Vineyard Priced at $14.25M

Summer 2026 is just beginning, and the possibilities are endless. Especially if you have a massive budget for travel or second-home buying. For example, if house-hunting for something coastal in the $10 million+ range fits into your summer plans, this stunning offering on Martha’s Vineyard may be just the ticket.

Asking a lofty $14.25 million, Connaught House sits in the heart of Edgartown just steps from shops and restaurants as well as the water. It dates back to 1880, which isn’t too old for the historic New England island considering it was settled in the mid-1600s. More recently, this compound with a main house, pool, and pool house was carefully renovated by Stern McCafferty Architecture + Interiors. They kept with the residence’s inherent Colonial roots, working to highlight the architectural beauty and emphasizing an airy, coastal feel.

You can see they didn’t push the boundaries, but rather kept things classic. The color palette is what one would expect from a high-end Martha’s Vineyard home: Shades of organic neutrals, whites, and blues. The outdoor spaces also meet or exceed expectations for this price point. Whether you’re unwinding in the pool house or cooking in the main kitchen, the tree-filled grounds and pool are always in view begging to be enjoyed at this precious, sunny time of year in New England.

In total, the property delivers six bedrooms within 4,860 square feet of living space. That’s certainly enough space for bringing friends and family along this summer, though they may insist it becomes a standing tradition. It’s a reasonable response. The Obamas also got hooked on Martha’s Vineyard, renting often until they eventually purchased their own hideaway.

Thomas Wallace of Sotheby’s International Realty holds the listing.