From Drew Barrymore’s former home, which she sold last year, to a contemporary masterpiece with an IDA-winning kitchen, Sagaponack is full of special properties. However, only 16 homes in the Hamptons town are designated historic structures. This circa-1750 residence listed for $3.995 million is one of them.
Known as Mott-Topping House, the home is older than the United States yet perfectly livable for our modern age. Its antique architecture and tailored, cottagecore touches create a balance of cozy and bright vibes that greet you like a warm hug. And, this is especially thanks to the head-to-toe renovation the sellers executed here. They restored details like original wood beams and period craftsmanship, while adding in modern comforts, all-new infrastructure, and designer fixtures. Bespoke tilework, solid oak doors, rebuilt mantels, and a divine kitchen with Michelangelo marble, a Shaw farmhouse sink, and top-of-the-line appliances also await.
An ideal size for an endearing (rather than flashy) East End retreat, the historic main house offers three bedrooms and 2,200 square feet of living space. Steps away, the property’s agrarian roots are on full display at the 1,500‑square‑foot barn, which could become a party barn, an art workshop, or whatever one’s heart desires.
Adam Hofer of Douglas Elliman holds the listing.
