If walls could talk, this 1840s Captain Row’s home in Sag Harbor Village would have quite the tale to tell. From its origins as a seafarer’s residence to its cozy lower level’s colorful past as a speakeasy, this meticulously-restored charmer carries nearly two centuries of history along with the comforts of modern living.
Listed for $4.9 million, 330 Main Street is piece of Sag Harbor’s legacy that dates back to its days as a bustling whaling port. Captain’s Row, as it is still called today, is a stretch of the village where sea captains lived in the 19th century.
Set against the backdrop of Sag Harbor Cove and Otter Pond, this four-bedroom, three-bathroom residence retains the good bones of a shingle-style antique, while recent updates have introduced chic bathrooms, textured wallpapers, and vibrant hues that bring a fresh, youthful energy to the home. Even in the heart of winter, this 2,500-square-foot haven exudes warmth with six strategically placed fireplaces, offering both gas and wood-burning options.
Picturing day-to-day life here paints quite a nice picture…Imagine mornings relaxing with a cup of coffee on the sitting room’s built-in banquette, afternoons unwinding by the heated gunite plunge pool or gardening in the backyard, and evenings entertaining guests in the glossy yet eclectic living areas. And, when that night comes to a close, a separate guest suite guarantees your visitors a comfortable retreat. The home boasts four bedrooms in total, so there is space for many friends to stay.
This historic spread is only steps from Sag Harbor’s shops, many of which are in buildings that also harken to the village’s early era. So, it’s is a prime buying opportunity if you an want to walk the same streets as the whalers of old Sag Harbor, dine at acclaimed restaurants, and easily get to scenic beaches nearby.
Hedgerow Exclusive Properties holds the listing.
