One of Brooklyn Heights’ Oldest Surviving Wooden Homes Can Be Yours for $4.9M

1/26

2/26

3/26

4/26

5/26

6/26

7/26

8/26

9/26

10/26

11/26

12/26

13/26

14/26

15/26

16/26

17/26

18/26

19/26

20/26

21/26

22/26

23/26

24/26

25/26

26/26

One of Brooklyn Heights’ oldest surviving wooden homes, dating back to the late 18th century, has hit the market for $4.9 million. Carefully restored by a preservation-minded owner to keep its original character rather than being modernized, its authenticity is striking. Raw textures and historic materials are kept throughout, making this a standout in a city full of the sleek finishes, marble surfaces, and floor-to-ceiling windows typically seen on the market.

Looks can be deceiving, and while it seems quite compact from the outside, the residence offers a little over 3,000 square feet and spans across four floors. It includes four bedrooms, just one full bathroom and a half bath along with charming spaces like the parlor, library, dining room, and kitchen.

The parlor is especially distinctive and feels beautifully antique, preserved, and unusually calm for a New York City space. Its minimalism really defines the room and allows the historical elements to stand out even more. Wide-plank wooden floors and walls left in a raw plaster finish create a textured look that adds thoughtful and intentional dimension. It also houses a wood-burning fireplace that serves as the main focal point.

Unlike many other homes in the Big Apple, 25 Cranberry Street isn’t about modern luxury or stepping into the future, but instead about owning a rare and nearly untouched piece of 18th-century Brooklyn. For those with a love of history and special finds, this might be the place for you.

Joan Goldberg with Brown Harris Stevens holds the listing.